Proton Calorimetry/Meetings/2017/12/13: Difference between revisions

From PBTWiki
Jump to navigation Jump to search
(Created page with "== Minutes for UCL Proton Calorimetry Meeting, 6th December 2017 (D17, Physics & Astronomy, UCL) == === Present === '''Simon Jolly''', '''Laurent Kelleter''', '''Anastasia Bash...")
 
No edit summary
 
(2 intermediate revisions by the same user not shown)
Line 6: Line 6:


'''Matthieu Hentz''':
'''Matthieu Hentz''':
* Refining Clatterbridge simulations:
* Refining Clatterbridge simulations:
** Noticed that particles were getting through a gap between the dosimetry box and the nozzle: due to Geant having difficulties with coinciding boundaries.  
** Noticed that particles were getting through a gap between the dosimetry box and the nozzle: due to Geant having difficulties with coinciding boundaries.  
Line 12: Line 11:
* Completing coursework and reading up on proton CT.
* Completing coursework and reading up on proton CT.


'''DW''':
'''ABF''':
* Fixed smearing of energy resolution in simulations:
** Was smearing pre and post simulations: post-simulation always used 8.5%; now only smearing pre-simulation with variable resolution.
** Now correlation between Monte Carlo truth and reconstructed energy spectrum.
** Still seeing low energy tail.


* Working on [http://www.hep.ucl.ac.uk/pbt/wikiData/presentations/2017/DW_LeCroyRoutines_06-12-17.pptx ROOT fitting for LeCroy binary data]:
'''LK''':
** Two classes for loading (LeCroyData) and analysing (LeCroySpectrum) data.
* PPRIG was good!
** Methods that get time/voltage arrays for individual triggers reset time to zero.
** Mike Merchant wants particle spectra for Geant4-DNA simulations.
** Current integration in LeCroySpectrum chooses region based on voltage levels: '''SJ''' and '''LK''' suggested more robust to use time window.  '''ABF''' said Caen integration window 100–200 ns.
** Very helpful comments during evening meal...
* Will contact '''Tony Price''' at Birmingham regarding taking some data with trackers!
** Not sure whether initial proton retains 'primary proton' ID.
* Everything should be finished with paper:
** Waiting for Adam to write his parts and polish off.
** Clinical part needed from Richard Amos.
** No answer from Tracey Underwood: becoming less likely...
* Lots of code housekeeping!
* Will contact '''Michaela Esposito''' and '''Tony Price''' about ISDI sensors.


'''JS''':
'''JS''':
* Investigating alternative methods for [http://www.hep.ucl.ac.uk/pbt/wikiData/presentations/2017/JS_Different_Curve_fitting_method_6-12-17.pptx fitting to Matthieu's simulated energy spectrum for Clatterbridge data].
* Gone back to looking into CAD modelling in Geant4.
* Going through Matthieu's Clatterbridge simulations:
** Learning how simulations run.
** Investigating introducing sensitive detectors for particle measurements.


'''ABF''':
'''DW''':
* Investigating [http://www.hep.ucl.ac.uk/pbt/wikiData/presentations/2017/ABF_groupMeeting_06.12.17_fitStudies.pdf difference between MC truth and energy resolution returned by fit]:
* Improved code to integrate waveforms.
** Adjusting energy resolution of scintillator (nominally 8.5%): gives Monte Carlo truth resolution of 1.36% at 60MeV.
* Reconstructed Caen ADC spectrum: needs corresponding LeCroy binary files.
** Fit resolution doesn't change with increasing energy resolution.
** Spectra look very similar for different scintillator resolutions: overlap within error?
** Will run simulations with very small resolutions and dig further into fit.
* Will chase up Hamamatsu regarding flat panels.
 
'''MH''':
* Run Clatterbridge simulations with angled stopper:
** Largest angular offset of 15 degrees means 0.75mm difference in depth.
** Angle offset causes spectrum to flatten.
 
'''LK''':
* Has written a talk for PPRIG...

Latest revision as of 15:02, 13 December 2017

Minutes for UCL Proton Calorimetry Meeting, 6th December 2017 (D17, Physics & Astronomy, UCL)

Present

Simon Jolly, Laurent Kelleter, Anastasia Basharina-Freshville, Jordan Silverman, Dan Walker

Matthieu Hentz:

  • Refining Clatterbridge simulations:
    • Noticed that particles were getting through a gap between the dosimetry box and the nozzle: due to Geant having difficulties with coinciding boundaries.
    • Fixed by putting a brass ring around the nozzle on the outside of the box.
  • Completing coursework and reading up on proton CT.

ABF:

  • Fixed smearing of energy resolution in simulations:
    • Was smearing pre and post simulations: post-simulation always used 8.5%; now only smearing pre-simulation with variable resolution.
    • Now correlation between Monte Carlo truth and reconstructed energy spectrum.
    • Still seeing low energy tail.

LK:

  • PPRIG was good!
    • Mike Merchant wants particle spectra for Geant4-DNA simulations.
    • Very helpful comments during evening meal...
    • Not sure whether initial proton retains 'primary proton' ID.
  • Everything should be finished with paper:
    • Waiting for Adam to write his parts and polish off.
    • Clinical part needed from Richard Amos.
    • No answer from Tracey Underwood: becoming less likely...
  • Lots of code housekeeping!
  • Will contact Michaela Esposito and Tony Price about ISDI sensors.

JS:

  • Gone back to looking into CAD modelling in Geant4.
  • Going through Matthieu's Clatterbridge simulations:
    • Learning how simulations run.
    • Investigating introducing sensitive detectors for particle measurements.

DW:

  • Improved code to integrate waveforms.
  • Reconstructed Caen ADC spectrum: needs corresponding LeCroy binary files.
Retrieved from "https://www.hep.ucl.ac.uk/pbt/pbtWiki/index.php?title=Proton_Calorimetry/Meetings/2017/12/13&oldid=1204"